I'd like to start this post by introducing you (those of you who didn't know her) to Muffin:

My family got Muffin as a puppy when I was about 8 years old. She was an American Pit Bull Terrier, and was absolutely the greatest dog I ever knew. She slept on my little brother's bed, put up with it when we'd dress her in our clothes, and the only time she ever bit anyone was when she was 8 weeks old and accidentally got my mom's finger when she was feeding her a piece of chicken. People who knew Muffin loved her. She was the sweetest, kindest dog, and she was very smart and very tough. I'll never forget the day she came home from wandering around and she had a tire track going right across the middle of her back--she was totally fine, she'd just been run over by a truck. Go figure.
Needless to say, I miss Muffin a great deal. She was put down at age 15 because old age had just destroyed her quality of life. Over the last few years as Matt and I have talked about getting another dog, I've leaned more and more toward getting another pit bull. I simply cannot think of a better family dog. As a recent article in Time magazine pointed out:
These often terrifying animals demand pity because they have had the misfortune of meeting up with the most dangerous breed of all: the human. "Pit bulls have gotten this bad reputation because of the type of people who own them," says Humane Society investigator Tim Rickey, who led the July rescue. If these muscular terriers have a flaw, their defenders maintain, it is an excess of devotion. "Their love for humans is why this breed is in trouble," says McBee. "They will take the abuse."
The dogs have never been the problem; the owners are the problem. I've met a huge number of pit bulls through working with the Forest Service as I went into folks' camps, and only once did I have an owner say, "You probably shouldn't pet him." The rest of the dogs were so happy to see a new friend that they tried to lick my skin off. I would love to have one in our home.
All that said, I got online last night and started looking at the local pit bull rescue web page. Today we went and met Dayzee May. She's an adorable 2 year old who looks EXACTLY like the dog on "The LIttle Rascals," right down to the black eye patch. She's very, very sweet.
However. However. As we were playing with her, we noticed that she likes to include her mouth when she plays. By that I mean she bites--very, very gently. It's more of a graze of her teeth, but it's still more than Matt or I am comfortable with, particularly in a house with a small child. I know it is probably a trainable issue, but I don't think it is one I'm ready to deal with. I'm definitely not opposed to getting a rescue dog rather than adopting a puppy, but it has to be the RIGHT rescue dog. And I realize that with a pit bull, the stakes are so much higher when we talk about having a new dog. Yes, chihuahuas and poodles bite people far more often than pit bulls do, but in the rare occasions that a family pit bull bites, the damage can be a great deal more extensive.
So, I think we're going to wish Dayzee a happy future and keep our eyes open. Stay tuned, since there are a few more great dogs on the rescue list that we hope to meet in the days and weeks to come!